CBCP: Science Facts on the RH Bills (In Plain Language) — DEBUNKED!

05 Jul

Once again, the CBCP has denounced the RH Bill based on several baseless claims.


1. RH Bills will kill children.

When does human life begin? At fertilization, when the sperm penetrates the egg. This was the unanimous response of medical experts (including doctors from Harvard Medical School and the Mayo Clinic) at an eight day hearing of the US Senate.[1]

Do birth control pills and the IUD kill the embryo? Yes, the pill has a secondary “postfertilization effect”, according to the scientific journal of the American Medical Association.[2] The American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology pronounced that the intrauterine device brings about the “destruction of the early embryo.”[3]


When a parents opt to employ a contraceptive, the parents engage in a sexual activity but responsibly avoiding the woman to get pregnant. Whether it be a natural or artificial contraceptive method, it will not result to pregnancy, thus no fertilized ovum is killed.

Even among embryologists, the definition of the origin of life remains controversial. Not everyone of them are in unison when does life exactly begin. If FERTILIZATION is taken as the beginning of life, what life will be killed when a contraceptive will prevent ovulation (thus no egg is released to be fertilized), or fertilization (where sperm and egg cannot meet, and thus no life is formed to be killed?)? How can there be a post-fertilization effect of the pill when the pill does not allow eggs to be released to be fertilized in the first place? A simple logic and rational thinking is in order.

IUD has different levels of contraceptive effect. 1) the copper serves as spermicide, 2) it serves as physical barrier for the union of sperm and ovum, and 3) it MAY prevent implantation of fertilized ovum. First, the woman should have regular consultation with the health care provider to check if the device is in its PROPER place. Failures of IUD often is due to the woman’s poor compliance with regular check-ups.


2. The RH Bills will injure women’s health.

Is the pill safe? The International Agency for Research on Cancer in 2007 reported that the pill causes cancer, giving it the highest level of carcinogenicity, the same as cigarettes and asbestos.[4] It also causes stroke,[5] and significantly increases the risk of heart attacks.[6]

Given: All medications have a side and adverse effect, no matter how safe they may be. A person can have an idiosyncratic reaction even to the safest drug, such as acetaminophen.

Is the contraceptive pill safe? What does the contraceptive pill contain? The latest available contraceptive pill contains either pure progesterone, or combined estrogen-progesterone pill (at a low dose). The estrogen level s at a low concentration so as to avoid persistent spotting from pure progesterone pill.

Breast Cancer: Which component of the pill causes cancer? Estrogen does. Estrogen may cause breast cancer, myoma, etc. So if a woman has a regular menstrual cycle, meaning every month beginning menarche (1st menstruation) until menopause, it means that every month, she has estrogen elevation. This estrogen elevation is a risk factor for a woman to develop disorders related to elevation of estrogen, like breast cancer (in SOME, NOT ALL), myoma because the estrogen is “unopposed.” On the other hand, if the woman get’s pregnant, wherein, in a span of 9 months, she will not have menstruation, it means that there is also a 9-month period that she will be free from estrogen level elevation, this will be protective for her, thus lesser gynecologic cancers.

If the woman is on contraceptive pill where she becomes amenorrheic (no menstruation), then there is no estrogen elevation. This then protects the woman from generating breast cancer and the like.

A family history of breast cancer however is a very strong risk for developing breast cancer. Please remember these snippets:

  1. Not all breast cancer patients took contraceptive/hormonal pills. In fact, a colleague of mine, single, virgin, never got pregnant, never took contraceptive pills, died from breast cancer.
  2. Not all who took contraceptive/hormonal pills developed breast cancer.
  3. Males, who dont consume contraceptive pills, can still develop breast cancer.

Hypertension as a result of contraceptive pills is DOSE-RELATED. That was the older formulation. The newer contraceptive pills have lower concentration of estrogen.

Venous thrombosis: use of oral contraceptives is not associated with detectable hypercoagulable state, users at a greater risk for thromboembolism include women who smoke heavily, women with high or abnormal blood lipids, women with severe diabetes with damage to the arteries, women with consistently elevated blood pressures, and women who are obese.


3. The RH Bills will destroy the family.

Will the greater availability of contraception improve the conditions of the family?Contraceptives bring about the downgrading of marriage, more extramarital sex, more fatherless children, more single mothers, according to the studies of Nobel prize winner, George Akerlof.[7]

Lack of appropriate sex education brought about the sudden increase in teenage sex and pregnancies. Philippines is now the leading country as far as teenage pregnancy is concerned. What have the church done instead to decrease this incidence? Banning girls to wear sleeveless, short skirts when attending church? Boy, it was and is still very effective.

Contraceptives can bring downgrading of marriage? When couples plan their family, they will have limited number of children. This will then empower them and be responsible parent. Families are the basic unit of a society. An empowered family means empowered society.

4. The RH Bills will promote the spread of AIDS.

Will the use of condoms lower the rate of HIV/AIDS in a country? It will increase it, according to the “best evidence” in the world, concluded Harvard Director for AIDS Prevention, Edward C. Green. Availability of condoms makes people take wilder sexual risks, thus worsening the spread of the disease.[8]

Lack of appropriate sexuality education in the Philippines, lack of use of contraceptives, especially barriers (condom) has significantly lead to dramatic increase of HIV-AIDS cases in the country. Introduction of condom has lead to the dramatic decline of spread. Porn stars, who works by having entertainment sex, are not the ones with the most HIV-AIDS affliction due to condom use.


5. The RH Bills are based on wrong economic.

Is there a correlation between population growth and economic development? “No correlation” is the answer of Simon Kuznets, Nobel Prize winner in the science of economics.[9]

Is population control one of the ingredients for high economic growth? No. This is the conclusion of the 2008 Commission on Growth and Development headed by Nobel prize winner Michael Spence. The factors for high growth are: leadership, openness to knowledge, stable finances, market allocation, investment and savings.

Is there a correlation between population growth and economic development? Is population control one of the ingredients for high economic growth? What I know is, if a father earns 500 pesos daily, and he has 8 kids to feed, each will have a share of 50pesos/day. If a father who earns also 500 pesos daily, has 2 kids, each family member will have 125pesos/day share. The bigger the share, the more resources to use.
Philippines has 300,000 sq km geographic area, but not all is inhabitable as some parts should be maintained as a forest reserve, some agricultural land. According to WB report of 2011, the current population density is 302/sqkm. ( Ideally, the best population density should only be 50-100 persons/sqkm.
Will population control affect the economic growth of a nation? Do tell me.

Posted by on July 5, 2012 in RHBill, Sex Education


Tags: , , , , ,

2 responses to “CBCP: Science Facts on the RH Bills (In Plain Language) — DEBUNKED!

  1. crazycousin377

    July 8, 2012 at 12:16 am

    Doc, there is correlation between Economic Growth and slow population growth. You might want to look at these links:

    Incidentally, I made an “RH Bill Resource Page”, a collection of information that I hope will help the RH Bill in arguments and debates out there. Spread it around other Pro RH Bill people as well.

    • drclintonb

      July 8, 2012 at 1:59 am

      thank you so much for these resources. It will be a good read surely!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: